The case began when Professor Fares Haddad, a well-known orthopaedic surgeon who once operated on Harry Kane, lost his Bentley Continental GT W12 to thieves in January 2023. Below you will see information about is news which has been summarized The Football Insight.
The luxury car was taken from his driveway, prompting him to rely on his insurance for compensation. However, the claim was denied after the insurer discovered the vehicle’s tracker system had never been properly activated. Although the dealership had installed an advanced tracking device, the subscription required to keep it running was inactive.
Prof. Haddad believed the dealership, Jack Barclay Ltd., had handled everything at the time of purchase in 2019. Conversations and emails exchanged with a sales executive led him to assume the tracker’s subscription would automatically continue through Vodafone.
This misunderstanding became the foundation of a much larger dispute. Feeling misled and financially burdened, Prof. Haddad decided to bring the case to court, arguing that the dealership’s failure caused significant and avoidable losses.
Courtroom Arguments and Shared Responsibility
During the trial at Central London County Court, evidence showed that Jack Barclay Ltd. had indeed failed to send Vodafone a crucial email that would have activated the subscription. Judge Andrew Holmes concluded that this oversight directly contributed to the theft loss. Without the subscription, the tracker was useless, leaving the vehicle impossible to trace.
However, the judge also determined that Prof. Haddad bore some responsibility. Over four years, he never noticed the absence of billing or updates related to the tracker. Judge Holmes stated that a reasonable car owner would eventually realise that no payments were being made for such a vital security feature.
Because of this shared responsibility, the judge reduced the compensation by 60 per cent. Although Prof. Haddad initially claimed more than £82,000, the court awarded him £33,057, which increased to just over £37,000 with interest.
Read Also: Leeds United Shock Chelsea 3-1, Boosting Survival Hopes!
The Reduced Payout and Its Implications
Despite receiving far less than he claimed, Prof. Haddad still secured a significant legal victory. The ruling made clear that the dealership had failed in its duty to activate an essential system that directly influenced the car’s insurance coverage. The compensation also covered part of the financial losses from his hire-purchase agreement and temporary replacement rental car.
The case highlights how small administrative errors can have costly consequences, especially for high-value property. It also underscores the importance of verifying subscriptions or services tied to vehicle safety systems. Prof. Haddad’s experience will likely serve as a cautionary tale for luxury car owners worldwide.
For the dealership, the ruling serves as a reminder of the importance of thorough customer service and documentation. A single missed email ultimately led to legal exposure and reputational scrutiny.
A Surgeon Known for Treating Football’s Biggest Stars
Outside the courtroom, Prof. Haddad is widely respected for his medical contributions to elite sports. He played a crucial role in Harry Kane’s recovery from a serious hamstring injury in early 2020 while the striker was still at Tottenham Hotspur. Kane underwent surgery to repair a ruptured tendon and returned to training just months later, eventually finishing the season as the club’s top scorer.
The surgeon’s reputation extends through his leadership at the Institute of Sport, Exercise and Health, where he works with top athletes across disciplines. His involvement in Kane’s recovery became especially notable due to the season’s disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Today, as Kane continues his successful career at Bayern Munich and remains central to England’s national team, Prof. Haddad’s name resurfaces in the public eye—this time connected not to a medical triumph, but to a legal battle he ultimately won. Follow footballcoasters.co.uk for weekly deep dives into football’s biggest stories.